Manchester City Council will meet tomorrow to discuss the introduction of a controversial Public Space Protection Order. Fifty eight signatories to an open letter are calling on the council to oppose the proposal, which they claim will be severely detrimental to homeless people within the city centre.
An open letter addressed to Manchester City Council calls on councillors to vote against the controversial proposal to introduce a Public Space Protection Order (PSPO) which will “threaten the safety and security of homeless people in our city”, according to the signatories.
The letter has been signed by 58 people representing a wide range of organisations concerned about the homelessness crisis in the city who think the PSPO, which targets homeless people and beggars in the city centre, is a step in the wrong direction. Anyone found breaking the regulations in the PSPO, which could be done by resting in a doorway or sheltering in a tent, could be fined £100 – or face an even higher fine in court if they cannot pay on the spot. Those signing the letter included:
- Beth Knowles – Sustainable Housing and Urban Studies Unit, University of Salford
- Ian Allinson – President, Manchester TUC
- Nancy Wilson – The Co-operative Group
- John Catterall – Greater Manchester Unite Community Branch Vice Chair
- John Organ – Manchester Homeless Charter Partnership Board
The argument put forward in the letter suggests that the PSPO goes against the spirit of the Manchester Homeless Charter (MHC), which made many commitments, including treating the homeless with respect, providing them with equal opportunities and helping them on to a safe and secure home. The MHC became part of the Manchester Homeless Strategy (MHS) for 2018-23, which again made many laudable commitments to helping the homeless. The open letter states:
“In our view the PSPO proposed by the Council is in complete opposition to this vision and approach [in the MHS] . The PSPO will create a hostile environment for homeless people in the City Centre, it will increase inequality and it will threaten the safety and security of homeless people in our city.”
The letter also contained a collection of responses from homeless people in Manchester who were asked what they thought about the PSPO, one says:
“It feels like we are trying to sweep people – who are most likely weak, poor, vulnerable and disenfranchised – under the carpet.”
Manchester City Council will meet to discuss the PSPO at tomorrow’s Communities and Equalities Committee meeting which begins at 2pm. The final vote on whether to implement the PSPO will be taken at a council meeting on 26 November. The full text of the open letter is included below:
We call upon Manchester City Council to reject the proposals for a Public Space Protection Order (PSPO) across Manchester City Centre.
The PSPO proposals:
Under these proposals people who are sleeping rough, homeless people and those threatened with homelessness will face on the spot fines of £100 for:
- Obstruction – resting in doorways, stairways or the pavement;
- Drinking alcohol – other than in licensed premises;
- Sheltering in a tent – and smoking a cigarette or eating food;
- Urinating and defecating outside – when there are no toilets they can use; and
- Discarding needles or syringes – when there are no sharps bins.
If the person cannot pay, they can be prosecuted in court with a fine of up to £1000.
Our Shared Vision, Values and Principles:
In 2015, the Council came together with other statutory, voluntary, religious and commercial organisation to declare our joint vision to end homelessness in Manchester by working in new ways together in Manchester’s Homelessness Charter.
At the heart of the charter were guiding principles concerning the rights of people who are homeless and at risk of homelessness.
We declared that everyone who is homeless should have a right to:
- A safe, secure home, with appropriate level of support to create a good quality of life
- Safety from violence, abuse, theft and discrimination, and the full protection of the law
- Respect and a good standard of service everywhere
- Equality of access to information and services
- Equality of opportunity to employment, training, volunteering, leisure and creative activities
- We committed to good communication, coordination and a consistent approach across all services.
We pledged that people with experience of homelessness must have a voice and involvement in determining the solutions to their own issues, to homelessness, and in wider society
This Charter became part of Manchester’s Homeless Strategy for 2018-2023. The Strategy recognised that to address the problem of homelessness we need to:
- Address inequalities and create equitable access to skills, education, employment and health alongside housing;
- Ensure that personal circumstances are not a barrier to accessing services and opportunities;
- Give extra support to those who might need it to overcome these structural issues;
- Create environments for people to thrive;
- Build self-expression, increased well being, greater social inclusion and positive relationships in order to create a much deeper and more effective support structure;
- Focus on what really matters, rather than just patching problems, and take time to consider underlying causes and experiences rather than make assumptions;
- Work “with” people and families, not “on” them, as this creates change and enables people and families to flourish; and
- Offer people who have experienced long-term repeated rough sleeping access to whatever treatment, care or support is needed in their local community. Ensuring this support is delivered in a flexible and person-centred way to help reduce the risk of another period of homelessness.
We were all encouraged to work towards these aims together with the Council and the Manchester Homelessness Partnership using a strong shared vision and common approach.
In our view the PSPO proposed by the Council is in complete opposition to this vision and approach. The PSPO will create a hostile environment for homeless people in the City Centre, it will increase inequality and it will threaten the safety and security of homeless people in our city.
The views of people who are homeless on the PSPO:
In keeping with the value of co-production, which is central to the Manchester Homelessness Charter and Partnership, the opinions of people who are homeless were gathered for the first PSPO consultation. A summary of their feedback is given below:
- It feels like this whole thing is particularly aimed at people who are homeless
- What is the PSPO serving to protect? It isn’t the rights of people who are homeless.
- This is there for the businesses, shoppers, tourists, and citizens with money. For the city-centre economy.
- There need to be easily accessible city-centre needle exchanges or more places where people can safely dispose of needles. Addiction exists, we need appropriate support.
- Rather than further criminalising some of the most vulnerable people in society, we could provide safe and supported places for injection. It would be financially and ethically beneficial.
- It feels like there is a real lack of compassion surrounding this whole thing. If you have no place to live, where are you expected to go to the toilet?
- I think some people come into the city to beg because of austerity cuts, because they are being trafficked, because they have an addiction to satisfy or simply to pay for bills. We should be looking at why.
- If the Council had been able to safely and appropriately house me, why on earth would I pitch a tent in the centre of town?
- What may seem like litter to some people may actually be another person’s only belongings which are both useful and meaningful to them. We need more humane solutions.
- It feels like we are trying to sweep people who are most likely weak, poor, vulnerable and disenfranchised under the carpet.
- It must be taking so much energy, time and money to try to push this through – why is it seen as a priority for the Council? Think what we could achieve if people put that much effort into other things.
The False Assumptions Underlying the PSPO:
It is our view that those supporting the PSPO do so on the basis of false assumptions.
There is a Bed for Every Night:
Despite our shared commitments and efforts, the reality is that there is not a bed for every night for every person or enough support to meet their needs. It is therefore not true or fair to suggest that all homeless people can avoid the risk of being fined by simply taking up offers of accommodation and support.
People can be coerced or threatened into accepting help:
Where there is an offer of accommodation and support for a homeless person, but the individual is not ready to accept help, fining them or threatening to do so is not going to resolve the underlying problems.
Manchester’s Homeless Charter and Strategy was based on our experience as to the ways of working with homeless people that are effective – working “with”, not “for”, and building the self-expression, wellbeing, relationships and inclusion that gives homeless people the opportunity for real and positive change.
The Harmful Consequences of the PSPO:
In our view this punitive approach will:
- Cause serious harm to homeless people, as those who have nowhere to go to avoid the risk of punishment will hide in darker streets in the City Centre or move to the outskirts where they are more at risk from harm from others, less likely to be discovered if their health is at risk and further away from support services;
- Encourage negative views and assumptions about homeless people among the wider public and increase the abuse and discrimination that homeless people face; and
- Cause homeless people to distrust the Council and the services that work in partnership with the Council, making real and lasting positive outcomes more difficult.
The shared vision in our Homeless Charter is to put an end to homelessness in Manchester, not an end to homeless people.
We do not feel that our concerns or those of homeless people about the dangers of this PSPO have been properly canvassed or considered.
We urge the Council to reject the proposed PSPO and to return to the values and principles of the Manchester Homelessness Charter and Homelessness Strategy.
Paul Martin OBE – Chief Executive, LGBT Foundation
Gail Heath – CEO The Pankhurst Trust (Incorporating Manchester Women’s Aid)
Fergal McCullough – Director, The Mens Room
Amanda Croome – CEO Booth Centre
John Organ – Manchester Homeless Charter Partnership Board
Dee Lowry – Business Engagement Lead, Manchester Homelessness Partnership
Siobhan Pollitt – Chief Executive, Back on Track
Mike Wild – Chief Executive, Macc
Jo Walby, CEO, on behalf of the staff team at Mustard Tree
Matthew Johnson – Development Manager, Inspiring Change Manchester
Stephen Brown MBE – City Centre Ministries Manchester
Irene Brown – City Centre Ministries Manchester
Niall Love – Street Support Salford & Manchester
Beth Knowles – Sustainable Housing and Urban Studies Unit, University of Salford
Dr Andrea Gibbons – Sustainable Housing and Urban Studies Unit, University of Salford
Prof. Phillip Brown – Sustainable Housing and Urban Studies Unit, University of Salford
Judith Vickers – Lifeshare
Holly Eddleston – Lifeshare
Alice Sparks – Invisible (Manchester)
James Hutton – Mad Dogs Street Project
Dawn Kaveney – Manchester Mind
Nigel Allmark – PhD Student with the Manchester Homelessness Partnership, Manchester Metropolitan University
Mylo Kaye – Pledge
Karen Buckley – Manchester People’s Assembly Against Austerity
Daryll Pollit – Street Treats
Billa Ahmed – Homeless Aid UK
Michelle Hill – Homeless Aid UK
Susannah Gill – Don’t Walk Past
Johanna Royle – Ferney Lee Primary School
Carol Jones & Christine Harrison – Caring & Sharing
Jessica Turtle – Museum of Homelessness
Charlotte Hughes – The Poor Side Of Life
Jon Glackin – Streets Kitchen
Sam Butt – Myriad Foundation
Denise McCormick – The Ark
Jolene Hampson – Unity outreach Glossop
Charlie Barat – Homeless Support Project
Angela Barratt – Street Support Manchester
Naomi Collier – WalkaboutMCR
John Ryan – Greater Manchester Hub Manager, Shelter UK
Damon Spillane – Homeless Project Manchester
Susan Muir – End Result Group
Michele Morgan – Feeding Rochdale Homeless
Ian Allinson – President, Manchester TUC
Rabbi Robyn Ashworth-Steen – Manchester Reform Synagogue
Rev’d Cody Coyne – Cross Street Unitarian Chapel
Lauren Coulman – Noisy Cricket C.I.C
Nancy Wilson – The Co-operative Group
Lisa Atherton – The Federation
Jamil Abdulkader – Trustee, Noor Masjid Mosque
Saiqa Naz – Mental Health Practitioner
John Catterall – Greater Manchester Unite Community Branch Vice Chair and on behalf of Officers
Pritpal Singh Makan – Sikh Sewa Organisation (SSO Manchester)
Jo Morfee – Co-Founder, InnovateHer
Elizabeth Mora – Social Worker, Cornerstone Day Centre
Mr Maqsood Ahmad OBE – CEO, British Muslim Heritage Centre
Dr Elsie Whittington – Manchester Quaker Meeting
Sandy Broadhurst – Chair, Stockport United Against Austerity
A webcast of Manchester City Councils meeting tomorrow can be viewed here.
To read more on the subject of homelessness in Manchester – click here
Featured image: The Conversation
For more information on Public Space Protection Orders and the long history of criminalising the homeless – click here
Change to text – 7 December 2019: The article initially stated that the council would vote on the PSPO proposal at the Communities and Equalities Committee meeting at 2pm on 7 November 2019. The PSPO will be discussed at this meeting, the vote on whether to implement it will take place at a later council meeting on 26 November.
Change to text – 8 December 2019: The original headline referred to “Proposed legislation…”. A Public Space Protection Order does fall under the category of secondary legislation, but is more accurately described as an Order. An Order that can be introduced by local councils under the primary legislation of the Anti-social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Act 2014.