Just over a year ago, 22 people lost their lives and 120 were injured at the Manchester Arena Attack. It was a horrific hate driven act of mass murder, and my heart goes out to everybody affected.

One year on, 15,000 people gathered in Albert Square to pay their respects. The power and energy created in that moment was incredible, and it was a fitting to tribute to those who lost their lives. The #WeStandTogether hashtag was a popular one on social media shares of the event. But to truly stand together, we need to harness this and maintain its flow. These mass public gatherings only seem to occur after tragic multiple deaths or disasters, yet thousands in the city are having their own personal disasters due to austerity and a growing housing crisis. If it takes multiple deaths to make us stand together, how can we come together to stand against creeping injustices that don’t take life immediately but may increase illness and produce early deaths? The average age of death for somebody experiencing homelessness is 47 for men and 43 for women, and Greater Manchester experienced a yearly 42% increase in rough sleeping in 2017. And an increasingly hostile environment for disabled people in our social security system has seen a doubling of attempted suicides reported by claimants.

Don’t get me wrong, I love this city, we have two colossal football clubs and have been creating great music since forever. We also have a proud industrial heritage, and a history of fighting for liberty and human rights. I am a Mancunian, born and bred. I was born in Crumpsall Hospital, grew up in Openshaw, spent my teenage years in Gorton and spent my adult life in and around Levenshulme and Longsight. But in my 31 years of experience, we do not stand together, and our communities are becoming increasingly fragmented due to cuts to public services. Beyond our music and football teams, there is a lack of cultural, civic and community pride.

Our emergency services did a great job responding to the Arena attack, which is what we expect them to do, even with the reduced funding, manpower and wages due to austerity. Support and help has been offered to the victims and their families. But do we really stand together? Are we really this great city that does things differently?

Manchester has too many societal issues staring at us right in the face for me to believe that we do stand together. Far too many people are being abused. Far too many people are not being looked after.

Read our previous story: 99% of Manchester rooms to rent advertised are unaffordable or unavailable to young people claiming welfare

Manchester is not just the vibrant Northern Quarter, or the affluent Spinningfields, or even the bohemian Chorlton. These just provide a very thin veneer over a Manchester where there is increasing homelessness, inequality, food banks, personal debt and job insecurity. Overseas investors are allowed to build residential properties in the city centre and forfeit on their agreements to invest in affordable housing and essential infrastructure. The End Child Poverty coalition reveals (as of January 2018) that in Manchester Central, 47.5% of children are living in poverty – that is 12,935 children living below the breadline. In Gorton, a place where I grew up myself, that figure is even higher with 48% of children living in poverty – that is 13,163 children deprived of adequate nutrition, resources and opportunities.

Manchester is the spice problem, and other’s suffering from drug addiction with reduced access to rehabilitation support due to cuts. Manchester is the multitude of disabled people being forced to jump through increasing numbers of hoops for reduced welfare payments, while there is an abject failure in addressing the issues of why disabled people are less likely to be taken on by employers.

Until Manchester solves these basic problems, I don’t believe that we have truly stood together. Until we have a city that isn’t divided, a city that doesn’t ignore its most vulnerable, I can never be truly proud of my city.

We need to build a city that is together, at all times, on all matters! Not just at times that look good on social media. A city that steps out of the shadows of its football clubs and musical genius. A city that solves its problems and looks after its residents and citizens and holds the people responsible for this accountable.

By being part of this ‘great city’, we need to keep ourselves honest and do more to know what is going on locally and to demand more local news. Politics is something that turns people off but we need to have more awareness and concern with the decisions that are being made on our behalf, under our noses. Decisions that are being made that affect us all.

Manchester is rich with cultures and diverse in creed, we are all different. If we are to overcome problems and build this city, we need to pull together and harness the spirit shown in the commemorations for the arena attack. We have to work in tandem with our councils to provide them with our voice again, and make progress in overcoming our burgeoning societal and economic issues. Manchester is just a place on the map, it has always been its people that have made it.

Let’s stop telling the world that we’re doing things differently and actually do something different, and make the statement “What Manchester does today, the world does tomorrow” ring true again!


Andrew Smith – project director at Manchester’s independent think tank the The Public Purse

Feature Image – James baker

Share this article

  • Guest Writer

    This article was written by one of our guest writers. If you'd like to write for us, get in touch.

Reader Interactions


  1. I wholly agree, and appreciate the inquiry and write up here. I’ll be happy to share it. I don’t feel its enough to sloganeer that “we stand together” in Manchester, when we clearly do not, in many respects. The phrase is in danger of becoming as hollow sounding as “we’re all in it together” did for the national picture. I don’t for a second mean to underestimate nor denigrate the incredible, genuine and in some cases heroic responses of people, including services in Manchester. However, I believe this case needs to be made, so that we are clear of the very big task that we have in reducing poverty and inequality in this City.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *